Viewer Comments:
Magnificent stairs to be sure!
The use however of goosenecks at some of the transitions presents a slight "crippling" effect on the otherwise sweeping handrails. (I'm sure you might agree)
As you know, a project like this is simple in appearance but deceptively complex in execution.
Great Job!
Nicely done Jonathan. I rather like the goose necks.
Jim,
How could the rail be done differently?
Would you forget the newels and let the rail flow around on balusters?
Yes, ideally there would be no newel posts (especially on the inside elliptic curves) and certainly no goosenecks or cap turns (as they are a gross interruption of the elliptical falling line.
Over-sized balusters or newels can be used for support but they should fit under a continuous rail.
Another solution are the use of a few iron balusters specially made to match the wooden balusters and installed with suitable anchors.
A "true continuous handrail" is the very essence of these types of stacked stairs. When viewed from the top, the handrail should appear as an "uninterrupted spiraling line".
This stair in every other aspect approaches a "true masterpiece" and superb piece of craftsmanship.
I'm quite sure Mr. Schwall would agree as he has communicated with me. He explained that this stair was built according to architectural specifications which stipulated these types of fittings.
It's unfortunate that architects don't always understand the finer points or details involved with these kinds of projects.
Either way, this is a project to be proud of and I feel privileged just to comment on it.
I also wanted to ask about the "pole" (which I hadn't noticed before) which appears to extent the full height of the stair?. What are your thoughts on that?
Yea the pole holds something that has nothing to do with stairs - lights probably.
I have designed and built furniture for 40 years and to see this quality of work makes me want to sell my tools and go home. My jaw is still on the floor!
I'm with you McKay, he is a true artist. I would love to be his helper and learn from someone with so much talent.
Not to mention the floor... Awesome jobs!
Nice work but the goosenecks are really out of place. Beat the architect over the head next time!
