Cherry Or Alder Debate

05/29/2015


From original questioner:

What kind of wood is this?

From contributor ca


Variation in the grain to the left of the picture right side of pantry looks like cherry to me.


From contributor Ma


Looks like cherry to me also.

Mark

From contributor Jo


how about clear alder, no stain

From contributor da


Id guess alder or possibly red birch

From contributor Ma


When I look at the grain on the left stile of the door, I'd say alder, but when I look at the grain on the pantry panel, that's what looks like cherry. I haven't seen a grain pattern like that in alder.

Mark

From contributor Ke


Tree Wood, Just kidding...

Looks like Red Birch to me

From contributor ca


I guess the more important question would be what species would best produce these color values?

For this project I am thinking alder would be a good choice. The goal is to produce something that will develop patina over time and not turn terribly dark.

Cherry is generally a higher performing wood for kitchens because it is relatively closed grain and modestly tough but can get a little dark and somber over time. Maple is too bright and a bit too modern for what we want to accomplish. Alder being indigenous to the area is another good reason to go this direction.

But I think I will also look at red birch.
How is this for stability or machining?

Thanks guys

From contributor Jo


Go to rustic Alder job in the shop I'll try to remember to post a Picture in the morning there's no stain

From contributor do


Could this be bleached cherry??

I almost wanted to say alder but looks too much like cherry to me.

I am always amazed when a customer wants clear alder for a kitchen...it is too soft and will dent and scratch too easily with time.

From contributor An


The blotching makes me think it's alder or birch.

From contributor An


Although could be maple too.

From contributor KD


You can right click on the picture and search google for "Images like this".
The builder of the cabinets says they are Red Birch.

http://www.houzz.com/photos/3578851/Saint-Paul-Craftsman-craftsman-kitch
en-minneapolis

From contributor Jo


rustic Alder cabinets with clear finish

From contributor da


yea for me red birch

From contributor Ma


Good call Dan, and Kudos to KTD for settling this question.

From contributor Gr


100% it's red birch. I've built many cabinets with it. I think it's beautiful wood won't darken like Cherry and much harder than Alder. No stain just clear oil or solvent based finish, water base will not bring out the beauty of the grain.

From contributor La


99% sure Birch.

From contributor Do


Maybe my screen isnt great but looks to light for cherry more like maple nice wook any how.

From contributor Fr


Hard to tell from a picture. Age makes a difference. If it's 40 yrs old or older, they didn't use alder to make cabinets. They used a lot of birch and a lot of cherry.